Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreen

2021-08-31T21:52:29.824Z

Apostrophe

Slather - Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreen

A blog article written for Slather, Apostrophe's blog, entitled Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreen

Aimee PaikDoctorateDegreeAmerican Board of DermatologyBoard Certified DermatologistChief Medical OfficerDermatologist100A dermatologist is a doctor who specializes in conditions involving the skin, hair, and nails. A dermatologist can identify and treat more than 3,000 conditions. These conditions include eczema, psoriasis, and skin cancer, among many others.
California

Apostrophe

Dermatology

2021-08-31T21:52:29.824Z
Group CopyCreated with Sketch.
Slather Blog LogoBlack words on clear background depicting the word `"`Slather`"`.
search-512Created with Sketch.

Education

Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreen

Education

Mineral vs. Chemical Sunscreen

Medically reviewed by Aimee Paik, MD

Written by Annie Lam

Last updated 8/2/2021

Pretty much everyone is talking about sunscreen on Instagram and TikTok right now and for good reason. Applying your SPF is the most important step in your routine. It keeps your skin protected from UVA/UVB rays and reduces your risk of skin cancer. One of the biggest debates, however, is if chemical or mineral sunscreens are “better”. We’re sharing our derm-backed take on these sunscreen filters. 

The Two Types of Sunscreen Filters

While most people know sunscreens as “chemical” and “mineral”, these are just common nicknames. Technically, there are two main types of sunscreen filters: organic (chemical) and inorganic (mineral). Organic (chemical) UV filters “are a group of carbon-containing compounds designed to absorb UV radiation.” Inorganic (mineral or physical) UV filters are a group of mineral oxides that are commonly referred to as mineral or physical filters. Now that we know the two types of sunscreen filters, let’s talk about the difference. 

What is Chemical Sunscreen?

Chemical sunscreens use organic filters like octinoxate, octisalate, oxybenzone, avobenzone, octocrylene, and more. These filters work primarily by absorbing UV rays and converting them into heat. However, some organic filters like Tinosorb M also reflect a small percentage of UV rays, just like mineral sunscreens. Chemical sunscreens can get a bad reputation, but they’re completely safe and effective to use.

What is Mineral Sunscreen?

Mineral sunscreens use inorganic filters like zinc oxide and titanium dioxide. According to our medical director Dr. Paik, “Zinc oxide is the best sunscreen ingredient for preventing hyperpigmentation.” It also provides dependable broad-spectrum coverage. One common misconception about norganic filters is that they reflect all UV rays, when in reality, only about 5-10% of rays are reflected. The other 90-95% of rays are absorbed and converted into heat, just like organic filters. 

Is one better than the other?

All sunscreen filters provide good protection against UVB rays (the main skin cancer causing rays), but not all filters provide dependable protection against longer-wavelength UVA rays that promote hyperpigmentation. Some of the chemical UVA filters break down quickly in real-world use whereas zinc oxide provides the most dependable true broad-spectrum coverage. 

Mineral sunscreens with inorganic filters tend to be chalkier and can leave a white cast, whereas chemical ones with organic filters are generally more cosmetically elegant. Certain organic filters (like avobenzone) can be a bit more sensitizing on the skin, so our dermatologists typically recommend inorganic filters for more sensitive skin. 

However, it’s important to address that it’s difficult for people with darker skin tones to find a mineral sunscreen that works for them because of the aforementioned white cast. Many brands say that inorganic (mineral) sunscreens are “better” but this leaves minimal options for darker skin tones. Chemical sunscreens are just as effective, safe for use, and tend to have little to no white cast. SPF options with organic (chemical) filters are a great option for darker skin tones. 

In reality, it doesn’t really matter what type of sunscreen you use. What’s most important is that you’re applying at least SPF 30 every day, and are diligent with reapplying every 2 hours when you’re outdoors. So which sunscreen you decide to choose doesn’t really matter as long as you’re applying enough product. Our dermatologists recommend at least ⅓ - ½ a teaspoon for your face, neck, and ears. 

The Dark Horse: Hybrid Sunscreens

A less talked about option is hybrid sunscreens, which use a combination of organic and inorganic filters. These sunscreens combine the benefits of mineral and chemical sunscreens. They tend to be better tolerated by sensitive skin while being more cosmetically elegant than sunscreens with purely inorganic filters. Hybrid sunscreens are a great option to try out for a more blendable sunscreen that may be more suitable for sensitive skin. If you're looking for a derm-approved hybrid sunscreen, check out 'Screen - Apostrophe's own sunscreen that's specifically formulated for sensitive and acne-prone skin. 😌

Overall, when it comes to the big “chemical vs mineral” sunscreen debate, one isn’t really better than the other. They each have their own set of benefits. At the end of the day, what matters most is finding sunscreen you love and are willing to apply every day. Our derms recommend looking for broad-spectrum protection of at least SPF 30. Regardless of which type of sunscreen you choose, don’t forget to #SlatherOn your SPF!

Like what you just read? Sign up for our email list to get the scoop on skincare science delivered straight to your inbox.
Email IconBlack outline of an evnvelope at a 45 degree angle.
Group 9Created with Sketch.

Apostrophe's Service

What is Teledermatology?


Read More

Deep Dives

5 Acne Facts You Didn’t Know


Read More

Apostrophe's Products

Oral vs Topical Spironolactone


Read More

Apostrophe's Service

What is Teledermatology?

Here’s everything you need to know about treating acne and rosacea online.

Read More

Deep Dives

5 Acne Facts You Didn’t Know

We’re sharing five things you didn’t know about your breakouts.

Read More

Apostrophe's Products

Oral vs Topical Spironolactone

We’re breaking down the difference between these two hormonal acne treatments.

Read More

sign up for our newsletter here

Group 9Created with Sketch.
Email Icon LightTan outline of an evnvelope at a 45 degree angle.

Apostrophe's Products

Apostrophe's Service

Education

Deep Dives

Apostrophe LogoLarge black A with the bottom left point turned into an apostrophe.